A Study of Basketmaker III Black-on-white Bowl Motifs in the Four Corners Region
  • HOME
  • PROJECT
    • Curatorial Facilities
    • Four Corners Region
    • AZ Apache County
    • AZ Navajo County
    • CO Dolores County
    • CO La Plata County
    • CO Montezuma County
    • NM San Juan County
    • NM McKinley County
    • NM Sandoval County
    • UT San Juan County
  • MOTIF 1
    • Motif 1: Forms
    • A.D. 575-650 (pg. 1) >
      • Basic (pg. 2)
      • Reduced (pg. 3)
      • Joined (pg. 4)
      • NFS (pg. 5)
      • Through Time (pg. 6)
      • Basketmaker II (pg. 7)
    • Motif 1: AZ.E81
    • Motif 1: AZ.E84
    • Motif 1: AZ Tseahatso
    • Motif 1: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 1: CO 5DL1091
    • Motif 1: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 1: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT1
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT3
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT5834
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT8899
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT9360
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT11861
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 1: CO 5MT20065
    • Motif 1: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 1: CO 5MV145
    • Motif 1: CO 5MV1285
    • Motif 1: CO 5MV1644
    • Motif 1: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 1: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 1: NM 29SJ1659
    • Motif 1: NM LA2501
    • Motif 1: NM LA2506
    • Motif 1: NM LA2507
    • Motif 1: NM LA11610
    • Motif 1: NM LA80422
    • Motif 1: NM LA80425
    • Motif 1: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 1: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 1: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 1: UT 42SA8880
    • Motif 1: UT 42SA8895
  • MOTIF 2
    • Motif 2: Forms
    • A.D. 575-650 (pg. 1) >
      • Triangular (pg. 2)
      • T-shaped (pg. 3)
      • Line (pg. 4)
      • Through Time (pg. 5)
      • Basketmaker II (pg. 6)
    • Motif 2: AZ E7.11
    • Motif 2: AZ E8.4
    • Motif 2: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 2: CO 5DL309
    • Motif 2: CO 5DL1138
    • Motif 2: CO 5LP39
    • Motif 2: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT1
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT7295
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT9949
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT11861
    • Motif 2: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV1200
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV1285
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV1937
    • Motif 2: CO 5MV1940
    • Motif 2: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 2: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 2 NM LA2501
    • Motif 2: NM LA2506
    • Motif 2: NM LA2507
    • Motif 2: NM LA11610
    • Motif 2: NM LA61956
    • Motif 2: NM LA80422
    • Motif 2: NM LA80425
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA6757
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 2: UT 42SA8895
  • MOTIF 3
    • Motif 3: Forms
    • A.D. 575-650 (pg. 1) >
      • 45 Degrees (pg. 2)
      • 90 Degrees (pg. 3)
      • Through Time (pg. 4)
    • Motif 3: AZ E85
    • Motif 3: AZ E810
    • Motif 3: AZ NA3570
    • Motif 3: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 3: CO 5DL121B
    • Motif 3: CO 5DL297
    • Motif 3: CO 5DL310
    • Motif 3: CO 5DL1105
    • Motif 3: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT1
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT2858
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 3 : CO 5MT4545
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT5011
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT8565
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT8899
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT9949
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT11861
    • Motif 3: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV145
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV405
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1060
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1285
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1644
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1676
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1937
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1938
    • Motif 3: CO 5MV1990
    • Motif 3: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 3: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 3: NM 29SJ519
    • Motif 3: NM 29SJ1659
    • Motif 3: NM LA2501
    • Motif 3: NM LA2506
    • Motif 3: NM LA2507
    • Motif 3: NM LA5631
    • Motif 3: NM LA11610
    • Motif 3: NM LA57024
    • Motif 3: NM LA61956
    • Motif 3: NM LA80407
    • Motif 3: NM LA80422
    • Motif 3: NM LA80425 (1/2)
    • Motif 3: NM LA80425 (2/2)
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA3775
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA4989
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8542
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8880
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA8895
    • Motif 3: UT 42SA20977
  • MOTIF 4
    • Motif 4: Forms and Variations
    • Motif 4: AZ E81
    • Motif 4: AZ E85
    • Motif 4: AZ E810
    • Motif 4: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 4: CO 5LP39
    • Motif 4: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 4: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT1
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT3
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT2378
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT2858
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT4545
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT7295
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT7323
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT8565
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT8837
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT8899
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT11861
    • Motif 4: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 4: CO 5MV0101
    • Motif 4: CO 5MV145
    • Motif 4: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 4: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 4: NM LA2501
    • Motif 4: NM LA2506
    • Motif 4: NM LA2507
    • Motif 4: NM LA5631
    • Motif 4: NM LA11610
    • Motif 4: NM LA80407
    • Motif 4: NM LA80422
    • Motif 4: NM LA80425
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA4989
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA6757
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA8880
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA8895
    • Motif 4: UT 42SA20977
  • MOTIF 5
    • Motif 5: Forms and Variations
    • Motif 5: AZ E81
    • Motif 5: AZ E85
    • Motif 5: AZ NA3570
    • Motif 5: AZ Tseahatso
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL121B
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL309
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL310
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL1091
    • Motif 5: CO 5DL1105
    • Motif 5: CO 5LP39
    • Motif 5: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 5: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT1
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT2858
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT4545
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT5011
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT7295
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT7323
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT8565
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT8837
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT8899
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9072 (1/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9072 (2/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9072 (3/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT9949
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT11861 (1/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT11861 (2/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT11861 (3/3)
    • Motif 5: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV118
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV145
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV283
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV405
    • Motif 5: CO 5MV1060
    • Motif 5: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 5: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 5: NM 29SJ1659
    • Motif 5 NM LA2501
    • Motif 5: NM LA2506
    • Motif 5: NM LA2507
    • Motif 5: NM LA11610
    • Motif 5: NM LA61956
    • Motif 5: NM LA80407
    • Motif 5: NM LA80422
    • Motif 5: NM LA80425
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA2
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA620
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA4989
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA6396 (1/2)
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA6396 (2/2)
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA6403
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA6757
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8542
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8545
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8876
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8880
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8889
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8895 (1/2)
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA8895 (2/2)
    • Motif 5: UT 42SA20977
  • MOTIF 6
    • Motif 6: Forms and Variations
    • Motif 6: AZ E81
    • Motif 6: AZ E:8:10
    • Motif 6: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 6: CO 5DL310
    • Motif 6: CO 5DL1091
    • Motif 6: CO 5DL1138
    • Motif 6: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 6: CO 5LP10843
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT1 (1)
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT3
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT2858
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT4545
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT7323
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT8822
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT11861 (1)
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT11861 (2)
    • Motif 6: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 6: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 6: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 6: CO 5MV405
    • Motif 6: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 6: NM 29SJ1659
    • Motif 6: NM LA2501
    • Motif 6: NM LA2506
    • Motif 6: NM LA2507
    • Motif 6: NM LA61956
    • Motif 6: NM LA80407
    • Motif 6: NM LA80422
    • Motif 6: NM LA80425
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA7
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA6403
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA6757
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8545
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8821
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8880
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA8895
    • Motif 6: UT 42SA20977
  • MOTIF 7
    • Motif 7: Forms and Variations
    • Motif 7: AZ E8.10
    • Motif 7: AZ Tseahatso
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL112
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL297
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL309
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL310
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL1091
    • Motif 7: CO 5DL1138
    • Motif 7: CO 5LP39
    • Motif 7: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT1 (1)
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT1 (2)
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT2378
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT2525
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT2858
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT3319
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT4545
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT5018
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT7295
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT8511
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT8557
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT8565
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT8899
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT8937
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT9168
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT9387
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT9540
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT10647
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT11861
    • Motif 7: CO 5MT12205
    • Motif 7: CO 5MV101
    • Motif 7: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 7: CO 5MV145
    • Motif 7: CO 5MV405
    • Motif 7: CO 5MV1060
    • Motif 7: NM 29SJ299
    • Motif 7: NM 29SJ423
    • Motif 7: NM 29SJ1659
    • Motif 7: NM LA2501
    • Motif 7: NM LA2506
    • Motif 7: NM LA2507
    • Motif 7: NM LA61956
    • Motif 7: NM LA80407
    • Motif 7: NM LA80422
    • Motif 7: NM LA80425
    • Motif 7: NM LA83507
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA13
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA3775
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA4989
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA6757
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA8540
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA8543
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA8889
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA8895
    • Motif 7: UT 42SA20977
  • Motif 8
    • Motif 8: Forms and Variations
    • Motif 8 Caveats and Multi-Motifs
    • Motif 8: CO 5DL112 +
    • Motif 8: CO 5LP39
    • Motif 8: CO 5LP10201+
    • Motif 8: CO 5MT1 +
    • Motif 8: CO 5MT7295+
    • Motif 8: CO 5MT9072
    • Motif 8: CO 5MT9540+
    • Motif 8: CO 5MT11861+
    • Motif 8: NM 29SJ299+
    • Motif 8: NM LA2501
    • Motif 8: NM LA2506
    • Motif 8: NM LA2507+
    • Motif 8: NM LA80422+
    • Motif 8: UT 42SA2 +
    • Motif 8: UT 42SA3775+
  • Motif 9
    • Motif 9 Forms and Variations
    • Motif 9: AZ E81
    • Motif 9: AZ NA3570
    • Motif 9: CO 5DL112+
    • Motif 9: CO 5LP10201
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT1+
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT4684
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT5018+
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT9072+
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT9540+
    • Motif 9: CO 5MT10647+
    • Motif 9: CO 5MV117
    • Motif 9: CO 5MV118
    • Motif 9: NM 29SJ299+
    • Motif 9: NM LA2501
    • Motif 9: NM LA5631+
    • Motif 9: UT 42SA6396
    • Motif 9: UT 42SA13 +
  • BMII Textiles
    • BMII Textiles (pg. 2)
    • BMII & M1 (pg. 3)
    • BMII & M1 (pg. 4)
    • BMII & M1 (pg. 5)
    • BMII & M1 (pg. 6)
    • BMII & M2 (pg. 7)
    • BMII & M2 (pg. 8)
    • BMII & M7 (pg. 9)
    • BMII & M8 (pg. 10)
    • BMII & M9 (pg. 11)
    • BMII Summary (pg. 12)
  • SAA pg 1
Basketmaker II Precursor of Motif 1, Reduced Form, Type 2
Picture
Cat. No. 164790  Courtesy of The Field Museum
Photograph by Laurie Webster
Picture
Stylized drawing by author of top figure in sandal
It is easy to see the resemblance between the BMII figures (left and above) and the BMIII Motif 1 Reduced Type 1 (below).  They both display a triangular head directly attached to a pair of appendages (wings).  Or wait - is the BMII figure actually exhibiting two half heads?
Picture
Stylized drawing by author of Motif 1 Reduced Form Type 2

Basketmaker II Precursors of Motif 1, Joined Form
As will be seen below, the Basketmaker II joined style bears only a limited resemblance to the BMIII joined form (shown right).  The BMIII body box in particular is nowhere to be seen in the BMII style.
Picture
Three methods of joining figures are represented in the BMII artifacts illustrated here.  The first method, shown in both the basket and the sandal, involves connecting two three-tiered figures, one upright and one inverted, by their bases.  The second and thirds methods are shown only in the sandal.  The second method involves connecting the central joined figure, by means of two short horizontal base lines, to the two joined half-figures on the right and left sides.  The third method involves connecting, within each of the four zigzag rows, the three full and two half two-tiered figures by the use of four short horizontal base lines.
Picture
 MPC 1995.2.32.1     Courtesy of the Museum of Peoples and Cultures, Brigham Young University  Photograph by Laurie Webster
Picture
Stylized drawing by author of central joined three-tiered figures, with horizontal base line extensions (for joining left and right joined three-tiered half-figures).
Picture
Stylized drawing by author of central upright two-tiered figure, showing baseline connections with left and right inverted two-tiered figures.

Picture
PM# 16-9-10/A2906  Peabody Museum Expedition, Samuel J. Guernsey, Director, 1916. © President and Fellows of Harvard College, Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology
Picture
Plate 24.i  (Guernsey and Kidder 1921)
These figures, with their frames of stepped triangles, are displayed as isolated panels.  The basket probably had four panels originally.
Picture
digital tracing by author of portion of Plate 24.i

Basketmaker II Precursor of Motif 1, Basic Form
The Basketmaker II precursor (below) of the Motif 1 Basic Form (right) exhibits three unique characteristics:  (1) a possible headdress above the figure's triangular head, (2) stick arms and legs and (3) external genitalia between the legs at the base of the figure's torso.   
Picture
​
Picture
Picture
PM# 17-34-10/A3576 (Cave 11)  Peabody Museum Expedition, Samuel J. Guernsey, Director, 1916.  © President and Fellows of Harvard College, Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology
Plate 26.d in Guernsey and Kidder 1921
Back
Basketmaker II Textiles, pg. 5
next
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.